Blog

Key Differences Between OEM and Aftermarket Parts

When deciding between OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts and aftermarket parts for collision repairs, it’s critical to understand how they compare in terms of fit, quality, warranty, cost, availability, and performance. Each option has its pros and cons, and the right choice depends on your budget, repair goals, and insurance coverage.

Choosing the right replacement parts is especially important for vehicle owners dealing with insurance claims and collision repairs, as different insurance policies may only cover certain types of parts. Additionally, car enthusiasts and those who prioritize performance and durability should weigh the differences carefully, as some aftermarket parts offer potential upgrades while others may not match OEM reliability.

Below is a detailed comparison of OEM vs. aftermarket parts, breaking down their key differences to help you make an informed decision.

1. Fit & Compatibility

• OEM Parts: These parts are specially designed for your vehicle’s make and model, ensuring an exact fit without modifications. This precise fit is essential for collision repairs, where even slight variations can affect safety features such as airbag deployment and crumple zones. Using OEM parts helps maintain factory safety and performance standards.
• Aftermarket Parts: Since third-party manufacturers make these parts, they may not fit as precisely as OEM components. Some aftermarket parts require adjustments or modifications during installation, which can lead to additional labor costs and potential alignment issues that affect the vehicle’s handling and safety. However, some premium aftermarket brands design parts that fit just as well as OEM components.

2. Quality

• OEM Parts: These parts are manufactured under strict quality control guidelines set by the automaker, ensuring consistent materials, durability, and reliability. They undergo extensive testing before being released, ensuring they meet factory safety and performance standards.
• Aftermarket Parts: Quality can vary significantly depending on the manufacturer. Some high-end aftermarket brands produce parts that meet or even exceed OEM standards, especially in performance-oriented components like brakes and suspension systems. However, lower-grade aftermarket parts may use cheaper materials, leading to faster wear and reduced durability. It’s crucial to research aftermarket brands before purchasing to ensure quality.

3. Warranty

• OEM Parts are often backed by a manufacturer’s warranty, typically lasting one year or more. This warranty covers defects, premature failures, and quality issues. This helps to add an additional layer of protection and peace of mind, particularly for collision repairs where safety is a priority.
• Aftermarket Parts: Warranty coverage varies by manufacturer. Some high-quality aftermarket brands offer limited warranties, while budget-friendly options may have no warranty at all. Lack of warranty protection can be a concern if a part fails prematurely, leading to additional repair costs. It’s critical to check the warranty details before purchasing aftermarket parts.

4. Cost

• OEM Parts are, in some cases, more expensive because they come directly from the vehicle’s original manufacturer. The higher price is due to brand markups, dealership pricing, and strict quality control measures. Some insurance companies only cover aftermarket parts to keep repair costs lower, requiring customers to pay the difference if they choose OEM parts.
• Aftermarket Parts: Generally more affordable, aftermarket parts are a popular choice for budget-conscious vehicle owners. The lower price doesn’t always mean lower quality—some premium aftermarket brands provide excellent value and even performance enhancements at a fraction of the OEM cost. The variety of aftermarket options allows car owners to find parts that balance affordability and quality.

5. Availability

• OEM Parts are only available through dealerships and authorized repair shops, which can limit accessibility. Certain older or discontinued vehicle models may experience longer wait times for OEM parts, especially if the parts need to be specially ordered from the manufacturer.
• Aftermarket Parts are widely available from various suppliers, auto parts stores, and online retailers. This makes it easier to find replacement parts quickly, reducing repair wait times. Aftermarket parts are especially useful when OEM parts are on backorder or challenging to source for older vehicles.

6. Performance

• OEM Parts: These parts are designed to match the original factory specifications, ensuring reliable and consistent performance. They maintain the vehicle’s original handling, safety features, and efficiency, making them the best choices for daily drivers and those prioritizing long-term durability.
• Aftermarket Parts: Some brands focus on high-performance enhancements, offering upgraded materials and designs that can improve a vehicle’s braking, suspension, or fuel-efficiency beyond OEM specs. However, not all aftermarket parts are performance-focused—many are designed to be cheaper alternatives. If performance is a priority, choosing reputable aftermarket brands is crucial.

If OEM parts matter to you, check with your insurer about adding an OEM endorsement to your policy.

How Insurance Companies Influence the Decision

When repairing your vehicle after a collision, insurance coverage plays a critical role in determining whether OEM or aftermarket parts will be used. Many vehicle owners assume their policy will cover factory-original parts, but in reality, most insurers default to aftermarket parts to keep claim costs low.

Whether your insurance covers OEM parts depends entirely on your specific policy and the level of coverage you have. Some insurers fully cover OEM replacements, while others only pay for aftermarket parts unless you have purchased additional coverage.

Several factors influence whether your insurer will cover OEM parts or require aftermarket replacements:

• Standard Policies: Most auto insurance policies default to aftermarket parts unless otherwise specified. Insurance companies typically prefer aftermarket parts because they are generally less expensive, allowing them to settle claims at a lower cost.
• OEM Endorsements: Some insurers offer OEM endorsements, which allow you to request OEM parts for repairs. This usually requires adding an extra rider or upgrade to your policy, which increases your monthly or annual premium.
• Out-of-Pocket Costs: If your policy does not cover OEM parts, you may have the option to pay the price difference between the cost of an aftermarket part and an OEM part. This ensures your vehicle gets factory-original parts while still working within your insurance claim.

If using OEM parts is a priority, it’s essential to review your insurance policy before an accident occurs. Proactively choosing coverage that includes OEM parts can prevent unexpected expenses during collision repairs.

Why Most Insurers Prefer Aftermarket Parts

Insurance companies favor aftermarket parts because they are cheaper than OEM components, reducing the overall cost of repairs. By opting for third-party parts, insurers can settle claims at a lower price, which helps keep insurance premiums lower for customers.

While many aftermarket parts meet industry standards, there are some concerns about quality control and consistency:

• Cost Savings for Insurers: Aftermarket parts can be 30-50% cheaper than OEM parts, which allows insurance companies to minimize claim payouts.
• Variation in Quality: Some premium aftermarket parts meet or exceed OEM standards, while lower-cost alternatives may lack durability, proper fit, or long-term reliability.
• Potential Fit Issues: Poorly designed aftermarket parts may not align perfectly with your vehicle’s structure, potentially leading to safety risks or performance issues.

Can You Request OEM Parts?

If you prefer OEM parts for your repair, some insurance policies allow you to request them, but they often come with additional requirements and costs. Some options include:

• OEM Endorsements: Certain insurance providers allow you to upgrade your policy to include OEM parts for repairs. This is typically available as an add-on coverage option, which increases your insurance premium but ensures that only factory-original parts are used when repairs are necessary.
• Co-Pay Structures: If your standard insurance policy only covers aftermarket parts, you may be able to pay the difference between the OEM part and the insurer-approved aftermarket part. This option allows you to choose the best parts for your vehicle without completely covering the entire cost out of pocket.
• Manufacturer-Specific Insurance Policies: Some luxury or high-end vehicle manufacturers partner with insurers to offer policies that guarantee OEM parts. If you drive a high-end car, you should explore manufacturer-backed insurance options.

How Freedom Collision Helps Customers with Insurance & Part Selection
At Freedom Collision, our team works closely with both customers and insurers to ensure that only quality-approved parts are used in every repair.

• We advocate for OEM parts whenever possible, ensuring that repairs maintain original safety and performance standards.
• We help customers navigate insurance policies, explaining OEM vs. aftermarket coverage and how to request the best parts.
• If aftermarket parts are required, we source only trusted brands that meet industry crash-test standards.

The Role of Safety in Choosing Parts for Collision Repair

When it comes to repairing your vehicle after a collision, safety should always be the top priority. While cost and insurance coverage influence the choice between OEM and aftermarket parts, the most critical factor is ensuring that your vehicle’s structural integrity and crashworthiness remain intact. Poorly fitted or low-quality replacement parts can weaken your vehicle’s ability to absorb impact, deploy safety systems, and protect passengers in an accident.

Understanding how OEM vs. aftermarket parts affect safety can help you make the best decision for your repairs. Choosing the right vehicle parts can mean the difference between a fully restored, crash-safe vehicle and one that may pose hidden safety risks.

Structural Integrity & Safety Considerations

Your vehicle’s design and engineering are carefully calibrated to protect occupants in a crash. OEM parts are specifically manufactured to fit and function within this safety framework, ensuring that every component interacts properly during an impact.

OEM parts help maintain:

• Airbag Functionality: Airbags are triggered by sensors that rely on a precise structural response during a crash. If a replacement part alters the way the vehicle absorbs impact, it may result in delayed or failed airbag deployment, increasing injury risk.
• Crumple Zone Effectiveness: Vehicles are designed with crumple zones that absorb and distribute the force of a collision. Poorly fitted parts can alter how the vehicle crumples, leading to greater force transferred to passengers.
• Braking & Handling Performance: Inconsistent material quality in braking components, suspension, or frame parts can affect a car’s ability to stop quickly, turn safely, or maintain stability at high speeds.

While some aftermarket parts meet high safety standards, many lower-cost versions lack the precise engineering required to maintain a car’s crashworthiness.

How Poorly Fitted Aftermarket Parts Can Compromise Safety

Not all aftermarket parts are created equal. Some reputable brands manufacture high-quality replacements, but others cut costs by using lower-grade materials and less precise manufacturing processes. The risks of poorly fitted aftermarket parts include:

Misalignment of Body Panels & Frame Components

•  If a part is slightly off in shape or dimensions, it may affect the vehicle’s structural integrity. A misaligned door panel, hood, or bumper can create gaps or stress points, which reduce the car’s ability to withstand an impact properly.

Subpar Materials & Reduced Durability

•  Some low-cost aftermarket parts are made from weaker metals or plastics, which can fracture more easily in a crash. A structurally weak part may fail to absorb impact forces, leading to more significant damage to your vehicle and a higher risk of injury to passengers.

Interference with Electronic Safety Systems

Many modern vehicles rely on Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS), such as:

• Lane departure warnings
• Automatic braking systems
• Collision avoidance sensors

Poor-quality aftermarket replacement bumpers, fenders, or side panels may not properly house these sensors, leading to malfunctions that compromise the vehicle’s preventative safety features.

Because safety depends on precise engineering, improperly made or poorly installed aftermarket parts can create hidden dangers that may not be apparent until an accident occurs.

OEM vs. Aftermarket Performance in Crash Tests

Numerous crash tests have demonstrated how OEM and aftermarket parts perform differently in collisions.

• Fracture & Failure Under Stress: Poorly manufactured aftermarket parts may crack or break instead of properly absorbing impact, leading to more severe cabin intrusion and higher injury risks.
• Structural Misalignment: If an aftermarket frame or body part isn’t an exact fit, it can weaken the entire vehicle’s crash resistance, causing more significant deformation in an accident.
• Electronic Malfunctions: Vehicles with ADAS technology require precise calibration of cameras and sensors. If an aftermarket part blocks or misaligns these components, the vehicle may fail to detect obstacles or properly engage safety systems.

Crash test data reinforces the importance of using high-quality replacement parts, whether OEM or aftermarket, to maintain the vehicle safety features designed to protect you in an accident.

How Freedom Collision Ensures Every Repair Meets Safety Standards

At Freedom Collision, we take vehicle safety seriously and never compromise on structural integrity, fitment, or quality. Our repair process ensures that your vehicle is restored to its pre-accident safety specifications, regardless of whether you choose OEM or aftermarket parts.

Here’s how we ensure every repair meets safety standards:

Thorough Inspection of All Replacement Parts

•  Whether an OEM or aftermarket part is used, we perform a detailed inspection to ensure structural strength, fitment accuracy, and material quality.

Carefully Selected Aftermarket Parts

•  If aftermarket parts are required, we only use trusted brands that meet or exceed vehicle industry safety standards. We avoid cheap, low-quality components that could put our customers at risk.

Precision Installation & Calibration

•  We ensure that every replacement part is installed to factory specifications, maintaining:
  • Proper crash absorption mechanics
  • Alignment with ADAS safety features
  • Structural integrity for future protection

  Final Safety Checks & Testing

  •  Before returning any vehicle to a customer, we conduct a comprehensive safety review to verify that all repairs meet or exceed industry safety guidelines.

  Common Myths About OEM and Aftermarket Parts

  Myth #1: “Aftermarket Parts Are Always Low Quality”

  Reality: Not all aftermarket parts are low quality. Some brands actually exceed OEM standards in terms of durability, material strength, and performance.

  While cheaper, low-end aftermarket parts may lack strict quality control, many premium aftermarket brands invest in research and development to produce high-performance, long-lasting components. Some aftermarket manufacturers even specialize in upgrades, offering superior materials and advanced engineering that can outperform OEM parts in specific categories, such as:

  • Braking systems – Many performance aftermarket brands offer longer-lasting, high-friction brake pads that provide better stopping power than stock brakes.
  • Suspension components – Upgraded aftermarket shocks and struts can enhance handling and ride comfort, particularly for sports cars and off-road vehicles.
  • Body panels and bumpers – Some high-end aftermarket parts are built with stronger materials, improving impact resistance over factory versions.

  The key to ensuring aftermarket quality is choosing reputable brands and working with a trusted repair shop to verify the part’s fit and reliability.

  Myth #2: “OEM Parts Are the Only Safe Option”

  Reality: While OEM parts are designed to match factory specifications, many aftermarket parts undergo rigorous safety testing and meet or exceed industry standards.
  Most insurers and repair shops that use aftermarket parts are required to follow strict industry guidelines, including:

  • CAPA (Certified Automotive Parts Association) standards – Ensures that aftermarket parts meet or exceed OEM specifications for fit, finish, and performance.
  • NSF International certification – Confirms that parts pass safety and durability tests, making them a trusted alternative to OEM replacements.

  While not all aftermarket auto parts are created equal, selecting certified parts from reputable manufacturers ensures that your vehicle remains safe without sacrificing performance or reliability.

  Myth #3: “Aftermarket Parts Void Warranties”

  Reality: The use of aftermarket parts does not automatically void a vehicle’s warranty.

  Under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, a manufacturer cannot void a warranty simply because an aftermarket part was used unless:

  1. The aftermarket part directly caused a failure or damage to another component.
  2. The manufacturer can prove that the replacement part led to the issue.

  This means you have the right to use aftermarket parts without jeopardizing your factory warranty as long as they do not interfere with critical vehicle functions. However, if an aftermarket part malfunctions and damages the engine, transmission, or other significant components, repairs related to that failure may not be covered under warranty.

  For peace of mind, continually:

  • Review your vehicle’s warranty terms before installing aftermarket parts.
  • Choose quality-tested aftermarket parts to avoid potential issues.
  • Consult with your repair shop to determine whether an OEM or aftermarket part is the best choice.

  Myth #4: “OEM Parts Last Longer Than Aftermarket Parts”

  Reality: The longevity of a part depends on the manufacturer’s quality standards, not whether it is OEM or aftermarket.

  While OEM parts are designed to match the original factory specs, some aftermarket brands use better materials and advanced engineering to improve lifespan and durability. For example:

  • Aftermarket performance brake pads often last longer than OEM ones because they are designed for higher temperatures and heavy-duty use.
  • Aftermarket suspension components sometimes provide better wear resistance, especially in off-road or high-performance applications.
  • Aftermarket cooling systems may offer enhanced efficiency, reducing the likelihood of overheating compared to stock components.

   

• However, not all aftermarket parts are superior. Some low-quality brands cut costs by using cheaper materials, which may result in shorter lifespans and increased maintenance costs. The key is choosing well-reviewed, high-quality aftermarket parts that have been tested for reliability.
  

  Which Option Is Best for You?

  Choosing between OEM parts and aftermarket parts depends on your vehicle, budget, and repair needs. Below is a guide to help you determine the best option for your situation.

  For New or Leased Vehicles → OEM Recommended

  If you drive a new or leased vehicle, OEM parts are the safest choice.

  • Maintains Manufacturer Warranty – Some warranties require OEM parts, and using aftermarket parts could void coverage.
  • Preserves Resale & Trade-In Value – Vehicles with OEM parts retain higher resale value.
  • Guaranteed Fit & Performance – OEM parts match factory specifications, ensuring seamless installation.
  • Required by Some Lease Agreements – Many leases require OEM parts for repairs to avoid penalties.

  If your vehicle is newer than five years or leased, OEM parts will help maintain factory condition and value.

  For Cost-Conscious Repairs → Aftermarket Can Be a Viable Option

  If affordability is a priority, aftermarket parts offer a cost-effective alternative.

  • Lower Cost – Aftermarket parts are often 30-50% cheaper than OEM parts.
  • Wider Availability – These parts are readily available, reducing wait times.
  • Comparable Quality – Some reputable aftermarket brands match or exceed OEM standards.

  Things to Consider:

  • Quality varies, so selecting trusted brands is crucial.
  • Warranty coverage may be limited compared to OEM parts.

  If you need budget-friendly repairs, high-quality aftermarket parts can be a practical alternative.

  For High-Performance Enthusiasts → Select Premium Aftermarket Brands

  Premium aftermarket parts can provide better performance than OEM components for those upgrading their vehicles.

  • Improved Braking, Suspension, and Engine Performance – Aftermarket brands offer performance-enhanced parts for better handling and efficiency.
  • Stronger Materials – High-end brands use reinforced components that last longer under extreme conditions.
  • Customization Options – Many aftermarket parts allow for personalized modifications.

  If you want better performance and customization, premium aftermarket parts are often a superior choice to OEM.

  For Insurance Claims → Understanding What’s Covered

  Your insurance policy determines whether OEM or aftermarket parts will be used for repairs.

  • Most insurers prefer aftermarket parts to lower costs.
  • Some policies offer OEM endorsements, allowing you to request OEM parts for an extra premium.
  • You may be able to pay the difference if your insurance covers aftermarket parts, but you prefer OEM.
  • If an aftermarket part does not meet quality standards, insurers may approve an OEM replacement.

  What You Can Do:

  • Review your policy to understand parts coverage before an accident.
  • Ask your repair shop to negotiate for OEM parts when necessary.
  • Keep records of repairs—OEM parts help maintain higher resale value.

  If your insurance defaults to aftermarket parts, working with a trusted repair shop ensures you get safe and reliable replacements.

  Making the Right Choice

  • For new or leased vehicles – OEM parts protect warranty and resale value.
  • For budget-conscious repairs – High-quality aftermarket parts can be a good alternative.
  • For performance upgrades – Premium aftermarket parts often outperform OEM components.
  • For insurance claims – Understanding your coverage helps you negotiate for the best parts.

  At Freedom Collision, we guide customers through OEM vs. aftermarket decisions to ensure safe, high-quality repairs.

  Why Choose Freedom Collision for Your Repairs?

  When it comes to collision repairs, choosing a great repair shop is just as important as selecting the best OEM or aftermarket parts. At Freedom Collision, we are committed to providing top-quality repairs, expert guidance, and outstanding customer service to ensure your vehicle is restored to its safest and best condition.

  Expert Consultation on OEM vs. Aftermarket Choices

  Navigating the differences between OEM and aftermarket parts can be overwhelming, especially when insurance policies and budget considerations come into play. Our experienced team will:

  • Explain the pros and cons of both part options based on your vehicle type, driving needs, and budget.
  • Help you make an informed decision that prioritizes safety, performance, and long-term value.
  • Ensure that any parts used meet industry standards, whether they are OEM or high-quality aftermarket components.

  Access to a Wide Range of Top-Quality Auto Parts

  We work with trusted suppliers to provide:

  • Genuine OEM parts for factory-grade repairs.
  • Premium aftermarket auto parts that meet or exceed OEM specifications.
  • Specialty performance parts for drivers looking to enhance their vehicle’s capabilities.

  Our goal is to find the best solution for your vehicle and ensure that your repair is reliable, durable, and cost-effective.

  Commitment to Safety, Quality, and Customer Satisfaction

  Your safety is our top priority. Every repair at Freedom Collision follows strict quality standards to ensure that your vehicle’s structural integrity, crash protection, and performance are fully restored. We focus on:

  • Precision installation and calibration for a perfect fit.
  • Thorough safety inspections before returning your vehicle.
  • Using only high-quality parts that meet industry safety standards.

  We take pride in our exceptional customer service, making sure you are informed and confident in your repair choices.

  Seamless Insurance Claim Assistance

  Dealing with insurance claims can be frustrating. At Freedom Collision, we make the process simple and stress-free by:

  • Communicating directly with your car insurance provider to ensure you get the best coverage.
  • Helping you understand your policy and advocating for the best repair options.
  • Exploring OEM and aftermarket part approvals to find the right balance between cost, coverage, and quality.

  Schedule a Free Consultation Today

  Your vehicle deserves the best care and attention after a collision. Whether you need guidance on OEM vs. aftermarket parts, insurance claim support, or expert repairs, our team is here to help. We serve as your top choice for an auto body repair shop in Morgantown, providing excellent customer service and quality repairs.

  Need expert advice on the best parts for your repair? Contact Freedom Collision today for a personalized consultation!<