How is the value of a totaled car determined?

If your car is damaged in an accident, it may be declared totaled. You can expect your insurer to cover these damages if you have auto insurance. The insurance will likely cover the damages if the repairs cost less than your car is worth.

For instances where the car repairs are worth more than the worth of the vehicle, your insurance company will consider your car a total loss. In this case, your insurance company will reimburse you for the cash value of your vehicle, which is what the vehicle was worth before the loss.

What Determines That a Car is Totaled?

As mentioned above, a car is considered totaled when the cost of repairs exceeds the market value of the vehicle. Your vehicle may also be considered if it is unsafe to drive, even with repairs.

Determining when a car is totaled varies by insurance company and by state. Every state has a threshold for determining if a vehicle is a total loss, and insurance companies can use an even lower threshold.

In Pennsylvania, a car is considered a total loss when the vehicle’s actual cash value is equal to or less than the cost of the repairs plus the salvage value. The actual cash value (ACV) is how much your car is worth immediately before it is damaged, and the salvage value is how much the car is worth after it is damaged.

Your insurance company will use the make, year, model, mileage, and physical wear and tear, as well as the damage caused to your vehicle, to determine the actual and total loss value of the vehicle. If your vehicle is in great, newer condition, you will have a higher actual value than a vehicle that is older and more worn out.

What to Do After a Collision

If your car is totaled, there are several steps you should take, including:

File a Claim with Your Auto Insurance

Contact your insurer and file a claim like you would with any other collision.

Have the Damage Assessed

Your insurance company will send out an adjuster to assess the damage to your vehicle. They will conduct a visual inspection of the vehicle to estimate the repair costs.

Check Your Car’s Fair Market Value

Your insurer will use the actual cash value of your vehicle immediately before your accident to determine if the car is a total loss or not. You can utilize tools such as Kelly Blue Book to get an estimate of your vehicle’s fair market value. You can also find the value of our vehicle by searching for what similar cars in your area are selling for.

Get in Touch with Your Lender

If you still have a loan or a lease out on your vehicle, you will need to inform the financing company about the damage while continuing to make your payments. Stopping payment can have a negative effect on your credit score and make it difficult to get financing for a new vehicle. After your insurance company settles your claim, they will send a payment for the vehicle to your lending or leasing company.

Negotiate with your Insurer

If you think that your car’s estimated AVC is too low, then you should negotiate the payout with them by demonstrating how your car is worth more than what they are offering.

Look for a new Car

While the payout for your totaled car won’t be enough to buy a similar one, it will be enough to make a down payment on a new car to get you back out on the road!

Need Collision Repairs? We Can Help!

The highly trained technicians at Freedom Collision Center offer quality, professional collision repair services to the Morgantown area. We can help get your vehicle back in proper working order and out on the road in no time. Contact us today to learn more!


Author: Freedom Collision Center


Text for Author here

Recent Posts

February 3, 2026
With the autumn season upon us, it means that many deer will be finding their way onto highways. Colliding with a deer can cause severe collision damage, so it is important to take defensive driving measures to reduce your collision risks. Deer season in West Virginia will generally run from October through December, with a dramatic increase in deer population movement. While the frequency of deer-related accidents is on the decline, these accidents are more severe due to the advanced technologies use in modern vehicles that need to be repaired after a collision . In West Virginia in 2018, drivers had a 1 in 46 chance of hitting a deer . Many deer collisions involve front-end damage which can elevate repair costs when you must replace the bumpers, front headlamps, windshield, and advanced safety technology located in this area. Tips for Driving Defensively to Prevent Collisions with Deer At Freedom Collision Center, we have compiled the top tips we have for helping you drive defensively to prevent collisions with deer . These tips include: Pay attention- While this may seem to be a no-brainer, it is important to pay attention and stay alert while driving. Being alert will help you notice deer crossing signs and will also allow you to react quickly if you see a deer. Be careful from dusk to dawn- Deer are more active during these hours, so it is important to be extra careful while driving during these times. Reduce speed- If you see a deer or other wildlife on the side of the road, be sure to slow down to avoid hitting them. They move in an unpredictable manner, so caution is key. Avoid swerving- While your first reaction to a deer coming into the path of your car is to swerve, you should brake. Swerving can lead to you losing control of the vehicle or hitting another car or object. Be sure to brake quickly and safely. If there is one, there is more. – This is the general rule of thumb when seeing a deer. Since they travel together, if you see one deer crossing the road, you’re likely to see more following behind. Be sure to stay alert and allow for the rest of the group to cross. We can’t control wildlife and when they venture onto the road, but we can control how we react. Follow these tips for a safer drive during deer season in West Virginia. Collision Repair Services Unfortunately, even with the right preventative measures, you may still end up colliding with a deer this season . If you need collision repair , the expert technicians at Freedom Collision Center are highly trained and equipped with top of line tools to get the job done! Contact us today to learn more!
February 3, 2026
Getting your driver’s license is an exciting time in your life and milestone for many on their way to adulthood. Amid the excitement, it’s still important to keep safety in mind. Driving is a significant responsibility, so it is essential to enjoy this new freedom with caution and safe practices. At Freedom Collision Center, your number one local auto body shop, we’ve put together some tips for safe driving. Obey the Traffic Laws This one may seem like a no-brainer, but it is essential not to overlook any traffic rules while driving. These rules are put in place to keep you, pedestrians, and other drivers safe. From right-of-way to stops signs, be sure that you understand and follow the traffic rules. Wear Your Seatbelt It is crucial that you always wear your seatbelt and make sure that your passengers wear theirs as well. More than half of the teens in fatal car accidents were found unbuckled. So, be sure to buckle up! Drive the Speed Limit A leading cause of fatal crashes in young drivers is speeding. The faster you are driving, the less time you will have to stop your car in the event that someone pulls out in front of you or stops suddenly ahead of you. Higher speeds also lead to a more powerful impact and cause more severe injuries. Be Prepared for Accidents and Breakdowns In case of a breakdown, accident, or other emergencies, it is vital to make sure you have all of your essential driver documents, including your insurance card, vehicle registration, and your driver’s license. It is also recommended that you keep an emergency kit with items such as first aid supplies, a flashlight, blankets, batteries, bottled water, etc. Keep Your Car Properly Maintained By properly caring for your car, you can help prevent breakdowns and other potential accidents. Be sure to have regular oil changes, tire rotations, and tune-ups, check the tire pressure as well as the brake fluid and coolant levels. Be sure to also keep your gas gauge from getting too close to “E.” Professional Car Maintenance Services Keep your car in its best running shape with our car maintenance services! From oil changes to tune-ups, Freedom Collision Center in Morgantown has you covered. If you end up in a fender-bender, we can help with that too. Our expert team can repair your vehicle and get it back out on the road in no time! Contact us today to learn more.
Small Dents, Big Costs: The Hidden Risks of Delaying Repairs and DIY Fixes After a Collision
By John Highlander August 29, 2025
“It’s just a scratch… right?”