What Happens if Insurance Can’t Fix My Car?

When you are in an accident, what you can do with the insurance money depends on a few different factors. At Freedom Collision Center, we’ve put together a guide to help you navigate your car insurance in the event of a collision.

Can I Keep the Money from My Insurance Claim?

If you own your car fully, with no more payments due, you can choose to keep the insurance payout and use it for another purpose but keep in mind that your car may be unsafe after a collision, so it is recommended that you have the car repaired if you plan to keep driving it. If you still owe payments on your vehicle, you will likely need to use the insurance money for repairs, which will typically be sent directly to the repair shop.

What Happens If My Car is a Total Loss?

If your insurance company cannot repair your car, they may declare it a total loss. This means that the cost of repairs exceeds what the insurer would pay, and therefore they decide it is not worth repairing.

If this happens, you will be compensated for your losses up to the limits determined in your policy. Compensation can come in the form of either a lump sum cash payment or a replacement car. Depending on your policy, you may be offered a settlement that is based on the actual cash value of your car at the time of the accident. In this case, depreciation will be taken into account. If you choose to receive a replacement vehicle, you should compare the cost of the replacement car to the total loss settlement.

If there is a difference in cost, you may need to make up the difference out-of-pocket. In either situation, it is vital to keep all paperwork related to your accident and insurance claim so that you can provide proof of any losses or expenses incurred as a result. This can help you to ensure that you receive the total amount of compensation owed to you.

If you choose to keep the car, you will not receive an insurance payout. The car needs to be taken out of commission for you to receive your payout.

What to Do Before Filing a Claim

Furthermore, you should always read through your policy carefully before filing a claim so that you are aware of any restrictions or exclusions that may apply in the event of a total loss. Knowing precisely what is covered by your insurance can help you ensure you are fully prepared for an accident.

If you have questions about your insurance policy or what to do if your car is declared a total loss, contact your insurer for more information. They can help answer any questions and provide additional details on proceeding with a claim. It is essential that you understand all the details of your policy and what to expect in the event of a total loss so that you can be sure to receive full compensation.

Collision Repair Services in Morgantown

At Freedom Collision Repair, we offer a wide range of collision repair services performed by our experienced team of technicians. Contact us today to learn more!


Author: Freedom Collision Center


Text for Author here

Recent Posts

Parts Availability in Auto Repair: Why It Happens and How to Plan Ahead

May 13, 2026
Learn why parts availability can affect collision repair timelines and how Freedom Collision Center helps you plan ahead after an accident.

Collision Repair Trends + How Freedom Collision Center Helps You Move Forward

March 25, 2026
Learn what is affecting collision repair timelines, parts, and total-loss decisions, and how Freedom Collision Center helps Morgantown drivers.

Avoiding Costly Deer Collisions

February 3, 2026
With the autumn season upon us, it means that many deer will be finding their way onto highways. Colliding with a deer can cause severe collision damage, so it is important to take defensive driving measures to reduce your collision risks. Deer season in West Virginia will generally run from October through December, with a dramatic increase in deer population movement. While the frequency of deer-related accidents is on the decline, these accidents are more severe due to the advanced technologies use in modern vehicles that need to be repaired after a collision . In West Virginia in 2018, drivers had a 1 in 46 chance of hitting a deer . Many deer collisions involve front-end damage which can elevate repair costs when you must replace the bumpers, front headlamps, windshield, and advanced safety technology located in this area. Tips for Driving Defensively to Prevent Collisions with Deer At Freedom Collision Center, we have compiled the top tips we have for helping you drive defensively to prevent collisions with deer . These tips include: Pay attention- While this may seem to be a no-brainer, it is important to pay attention and stay alert while driving. Being alert will help you notice deer crossing signs and will also allow you to react quickly if you see a deer. Be careful from dusk to dawn- Deer are more active during these hours, so it is important to be extra careful while driving during these times. Reduce speed- If you see a deer or other wildlife on the side of the road, be sure to slow down to avoid hitting them. They move in an unpredictable manner, so caution is key. Avoid swerving- While your first reaction to a deer coming into the path of your car is to swerve, you should brake. Swerving can lead to you losing control of the vehicle or hitting another car or object. Be sure to brake quickly and safely. If there is one, there is more. – This is the general rule of thumb when seeing a deer. Since they travel together, if you see one deer crossing the road, you’re likely to see more following behind. Be sure to stay alert and allow for the rest of the group to cross. We can’t control wildlife and when they venture onto the road, but we can control how we react. Follow these tips for a safer drive during deer season in West Virginia. Collision Repair Services Unfortunately, even with the right preventative measures, you may still end up colliding with a deer this season . If you need collision repair , the expert technicians at Freedom Collision Center are highly trained and equipped with top of line tools to get the job done! Contact us today to learn more!